The Story of Sonny Dewey
The Apostle begins in dramatic upheaval. Sonny Dewey, a respected Pentecostal preacher in rural Texas, discovers that his wife Jessie has been having an affair with the church’s youth minister, Horace. Fueled by betrayal and desperation, Sonny’s emotional unraveling culminates in a violent altercation – he attacks Horace during a youth baseball game, a moment fueled as much by wounded pride as by spiritual despair. This act ultimately leads to Horace’s death and Sonny’s decision to flee his community, abandoning his past in a literal and symbolic way.
This sequence establishes the central tension of the film: Sonny’s battle between his charismatic devotion to God and his very real human failings. He is neither hero nor villain, but a deeply complex figure whose faith coexists with anger, pride, passion, and doubt. Rather than casting Sonny as a saint or martyr, Duvall insists on his full humanity – the good, the bad, and the irreducibly contradictory.
Escaping Texas, Sonny deposits his car in a river and destroys his personal identification, effectively severing ties with his former life. He reinvents himself as “The Apostle E. F.” and arrives in the bayou landscapes of Louisiana – an atmospheric, almost mythic setting that mirrors his own wilderness of spirit. Here, he befriends a retired minister willing to help him start a new church, and through sheer force of personality and heartfelt conviction, Sonny begins to build a new community of believers.
A Portrait of Faith: Authentic, Unvarnished, and Tactile
One of the film’s most striking achievements is its depiction of faith and religious experience. Unlike many Hollywood treatments of religion – which often veer toward caricature, skepticism, or sentimentality – The Apostle portrays spirituality in vivid, textured detail. The preaching scenes are electrifying not only because of their raw energy, but because they reflect a lived reality: sticky revival tents, shouting congregants, messianic fervor, and genuine emotional release.
This authenticity can be attributed to Duvall’s long engagement with the subject. His research into Pentecostal traditions and his fascination with the rhythms and cadences of preaching infuse the film with an almost documentary feel. The crowd scenes feel spontaneous, unrehearsed, and alive — as if the camera is privy to a real congregation at worship. This artistic choice elevates the spiritual dimension of the narrative and invites viewers into the emotional and theological intensity of Sonny’s world.
The Louisiana setting reinforces this realism. The bayou’s humid, moss‑laden atmosphere — with its swamps, wooden churches, and backroads — creates a sense of place that feels lived in and rich with cultural texture. This grounded environment allows the film to transcend abstraction; Sonny’s spiritual quest unfolds against a backdrop that is earthy, tangible, and intensely human.
Character Complexity: Sonny as Everyman and Prophet
Sonny Dewey is not a conventional protagonist. He is not noble in the way that classical heroes are noble; he is not perfect, nor is he consistently likable. What makes him fascinating — and what makes The Apostle compelling — is his complexity. Sonny embodies contradictions: he is charismatic yet self‑destructive, devoted yet blind to his own flaws, capable of deep compassion and sudden violence. These contradictions are not incidental; they are essential to understanding his character and his journey.
Film critic Roger Ebert praised this complexity, noting that Sonny is portrayed “with great attention and sympathy.” Sonny’s spiritual fervor is real, even when his human failings are on full display. His relationship with God is intimate and visceral — he prays aloud, sometimes almost pleadingly, and often searches for answers that do not come easily or directly. There is a rugged honesty to his belief, and Duvall captures this with subtlety and depth.
Sonny’s flaws are not glossed over. His temper, his impulsive violence, and his inability to fully reconcile with his past are central to the film’s emotional arc. Rather than presenting him as a man saved by faith outright, The Apostle depicts him as a man still struggling — a sinner seeking redemption, not through perfection, but through persistence and community. Sonny does not find easy absolution; he finds grace in the midst of imperfection.
Themes of Redemption and Renewal
At its heart, The Apostle is a story of redemption — not only in the spiritual sense, but also in the social and personal sense. Sonny’s journey is one of displacement and renewal, a kind of modern parable of exile. After losing everything familiar, he finds a new life not by escaping his past, but by confronting it in new forms. The Louisiana church he builds, small and humble, becomes a space where people from diverse backgrounds — including different races and social classes — can gather, worship, and find support.
The film also challenges traditional narratives of moral judgment. Sonny is not required to abandon his humanity or his flaws in order to be redeemed. Instead, he is allowed — and even compelled — to remain fully human while seeking to do good. This is an important distinction: redemption is not depicted as erasure of the past, but as transformation in spite of it. Sonny’s preaching to his congregation, to strangers, and ultimately to prisoners on a chain gang at the film’s conclusion underscores this idea. Even in adversity, his faith remains active, vibrant, and inclusive.
This emphasis on ongoing faith, rather than completed faith, is part of what makes The Apostle so spiritually resonant. It does not depict a tidy resolution where all conflicts are solved and all sins forgiven in one climactic moment. Rather, it suggests that faith is lived through continued engagement — sometimes messy, sometimes conflicted, always vulnerable. Sonny’s final sermon on the road gang, preaching to fellow inmates, echoes this idea: the calling does not end with punishment. If anything, it deepens.
Artistic Independence and Risk
Part of what makes The Apostle remarkable is the story behind its creation. Duvall wrote the script in longhand as early as 1984 but struggled for years to find a studio willing to produce the film. The project was dismissed by many as too challenging, too religious, or too uncompromising. Undeterred, Duvall eventually financed the movie himself, investing not only financial resources but creative autonomy.
This independence is evident in every frame of the film. Duvall does not pander to market expectations or narrative conventions. Instead, he crafts a story that is daring in its pace, tone, and focus. The screenplay allows scenes to breathe; sermons and prayers unfold in real time, and the rhythms of life in rural Louisiana are given space to unfold without narrative rush. From the sparse dialogue to the heartfelt performances of supporting characters, the film exudes an integrity that feels rare in mainstream cinema.
The choice to cast real congregants as extras, to film on location in Louisiana’s bayous, and to embrace a style that feels almost ethnographic all contribute to the film’s distinctiveness. These artistic decisions — born out of risk rather than conformity — are what give The Apostle its texture and emotional resonance.
Reception and Legacy
Upon release, The Apostle was not a blockbuster in the traditional sense – but it was a critical success and a cultural milestone. The film was screened in the Un Certain Regard section at the 1998 Cannes Film Festival, an acknowledgment of its artistic merit and international interest. Duvall earned an Academy Award nomination for Best Actor, and the film itself won the Independent Spirit Award for Best Film – a testament to its power within independent cinema circles.
Critics praised the film for its depth and emotional authenticity. Rotten Tomatoes reflects a strong approval rating, with reviewers highlighting Duvall’s performance and the film’s nuanced treatment of faith. Roger Ebert extolled the movie for escaping cinematic convention in favor of a portrayal that feels as real as a documentary, capturing the vitality of human spirituality without condescension or caricature.
What truly distinguishes The Apostle in the pantheon of American films is its enduring relevance. Decades after its release, it continues to be discussed not only as a cinematic achievement but as a cultural work that speaks to questions of belief, community, and moral complexity. Its influence extends beyond film criticism and into spiritual discourse, with audiences – religious and secular alike – finding something profound in Sonny’s journey.
The Knowledge Base 
Leave a comment